E-Ventors Student Life

Do Trust and Trustworthiness exist in online environments?

Category:




Trust as suggested by Rampet et al (1985) can be associated with interaction and past experiences while (Boss, 1978:Zand1972) defines trust as the willingness to take risk and not necessarily taking risk .While some other authors feel that trust could be associated with experiences that develops and originates over time.
There are attributes to trust which are credibility, reliability, consistency and communication. Is the organisation credible in terms of its reputation? Reliability is the when an organisation says it would do something do they really perform their duties.

Consistency is providing the same high standard of service throughout the organisation. Communication is keeping contact customers either by mails, phone calls and newsletters. The above factors can build trust within an organisation.
Trustworthiness could be linked with the trustee who is the party that needs to be trusted. Trustworthiness according to Crawford (2009) stated that trustworthiness in online businesses is anything that could be linked to the authenticity of the internet. Most researchers disagree with the theory due to the fact that anyone can do or say anything on the internet without permission.

In a B2B context trustworthiness might not work effectively if done online as a result of the distance between the buyer and the supplier as some form of verification are needed for both parties before trust can be applied (Ann Arbor, 2000.) There are three factors that could be associated to trustworthiness which are benevolence, ability and integrity (Olson, G. M. 2000).

Ability in trustworthiness could be seen as the various characteristics or skills that an organisation needs to create to influence a particular area of work. For example an individual that has a particular skill in the marketing department might have little or no experience in the HR department in this situation the individual would be allowed to carry out various tasks in the marketing department but not be trusted to carry out the task of the HR department which might be the recruiting aspect.

Integrity as suggested by Mc Fall (1987) could be categorized as personal and moral integrity. Personal is when a customer has adhered to the rules of the organisation that is considered acceptable and if these rules do not seem appropriate to the customer then the organisation would be measured to have integrity which can be seen as moral integrity. Some organisations could be considered to have a low or high integrity this could be due to lack of consistency.

Benevolence in trustworthiness is an important role in the ability for the party to be trusted to do something that would be beneficial or good to the trusting party which is the (trustee) apart from the main motive of making profit.
If it is an offline or online organisation /company that either delivers services or sells product. It is the ability of the organisation to deliver extraordinary service to the customers by attending to their needs without expecting an extrinsic reward.

Building trust and trustworthiness in an online environment is not as easy as in the off line environment. Trust needs the touch feel aspect (Judith. s Olson et.al, 2000), the phrase “people buy people” which is so often used in off line sales environments denotes the importance of the touch and feels aspect in building trust.

A survey conducting in the USA (University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, 2000.) carried out to ascertain what people felt about building trust or trusting someone over an online environment as compared to face to face interaction. People were asked how safe they felt trusting information they received via email, telephone and face to face. The online environment scored low as most respondents acknowledged that the feel touch element made them trust people more and although hearing a voice over the telephone also helped in building trust.

With privacy and identity being pivotal focal points (Chaffey and smith 2008) in online environments, it is also these factors that help build trust hence allowing consumers to take perceived and non-perceived risks. (Boss, 1978:Z and 1972).

So how do we build trust and trustworthiness and why is it important in online environments? How a website looks is a very important in building trust, remembering that our websites speak volumes of who we are and what type of business we are. What consumers see on websites helps induce them into taking the perceived risk that then leads to trust. (Kohl, Fichman and kraut 2009). Easy access to information and help points are key elements in building trust.

Communication is key in building trust(Morgan & hunt), hence setting up communication channels either by showing a physical address of the company, telephone number (preferable landline) and email addresses and where if possible faces of people that are behind the company. Having these aspects and more will help customers feel not only safe but assured that if they are faced with a challenge they can get help. Toyota during its crisis, managed to set up an online help centre where customers would ask questions on what steps they needed to take if their cars were affected and they would get answers. The idea was set on building trust which had been perceived to be in danger. Where trustworthiness is viewed as being able to keep consumers that trust us, one would ask how best we can ensure that these consumers are managed.

Customer relationship management (CRM) looks at ways of managing our current portfolio through communicating with them and continuously improvements (Kaizen continuous improvements) on our service e.g. security and transparency, in so doing the company is building on trustworthiness. Lloyd’s tsb during their crisis in 2009 engaged in a communication strategy with its customers in a way to build trustworthiness. They engaged in communication campaigns through adverts that which featured that they were voted the safest bank in the UK.






HSBC in a bid to build trustworthiness with its online customers because they were fully aware that the general public were sceptical on security issues pertaining to online banking, however as highlighted in the video (below) they created an advert that would reinforce their security in a bid to lure more people into trusting and using online banking.


HSBC Advert-Why Trust online banking




Many online companies including eBay and Amazon use feedback forms and star ratings from buyers (consumers) in a way to help profile their trust, trustworthiness and transparency of the services that they offer.


In Conclusion we agree trust and trustworthiness are fundamental in the online environment, these aspects still prove to be difficult to attain in a noisy online environment due to the lack of the feel touch element. (Judith. S Olson, et.al 2000). With almost zero to non regulation on the internet, many people can pose as impersonators of other companies by creating similar websites to that of the original company for example United Airlines have an impersonated website www.united.com and it is people like this that make it very difficult for trust and trustworthiness to be attained. With majority of companies using rewards to attain trust one the questions Can trust be bought through rewards? Is loyalty as sign of trustworthiness? The attributes of trust and trustworthiness form the backbone to the importance of trust and trustworthiness in an online environment.



References
Ben-ner, A. and Halldorsson, F. (2010), “Trusting and Trustworthiness: What are they, how to measure them, and what affects them”, Journal of Economic Psychology, no31, pp 64-79.

Buttner, o. and Goritz, a. (2008) ‘Perceived Trustworthiness of online shops’, Journal of Consumer Behaviour 7, 35 - 50

Comedy’s C., Hannula M. and Vaisanen J. (2009) 'Effects of Consumer Trust and Risk on online purchase decision-making: A comparison of finish and United States Students'. International Journal of Management 26(2), 295-308

Crawford, W. (2009) Authenticity and Sincerity [online] available from [10 march 2010]

Khar. B, Shahid. S., Akhtar, a. (2009) role of trust: brand equity ‘journal of Indian management pp 6

Koh, t. Fichman, M. Kraut, R (n.d) Trust across borders: buyer-supplier trust in global b2b e-commerce [online] available from [ 9 march 2010]

Mayer, R., Davis, J. and Schoorman, D. (1995) ‘An Integrative Model of Organisational Trust’, Academy of Management Review 20 (3), 709 – 734

Morgan, R. and Hunt, S. (1994) ‘The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing’, Journal of Marketing 58 (3), 20 - 39

Olson. J. S., Olson, G. M. (2000), i2i Trust in E-commerce, Communications of the ACM, December 43.( 2)

Generation X and the Homo interneticus

Category:

With the introduction of the World Wide Web (www), the internet has greatly evolved since its creation. Nowadays, people spend a high amount of their time on the internet for various reasons such as; communicating with other people either for social, economic and/or political purposes and more. Nevertheless, it has both positive and negative effects on humans by either influencing the way they live or think. According to a BBC documentary - THE VIRTUAL REVOLUTION-Homo Interneticus – the author Dr Aleks Krotoski revealed some arguments on the consequences of the web on people and its effect on relationships, lifestyle and more.

The documentary brings out three key points which are; the addiction to the internet by its users, the effects on relationships with the rest of the world (anti-socialization) and invasion of privacy.
Firstly, it has become a norm to use the internet in our everyday lives and activities given that it is the new centre of source of information. Be it in schools, organizations and/or homes, the internet is a mandatory tool for most of its users. Children today are exposed to the internet at a very tender age. Most of the things they are taught are related to the internet one way or the other. In this case, it has become an indispensable tool for their education. In the documentary, it is argued that children’s exposure to the internet at a very tender age creates an addiction. The number of hours they spend on the internet is sometimes outrageous. For example, 62% of children in the age range of 3-5 years in South Korea actually spend up to 8 hours on the internet compared to those of the same range in Britain. But, looking at the great importance of the internet in these children’s education and the fact that it has become a vital tool in all they do, be it at home or in schools it cannot be really considered as an addiction especially because of the way education is changing today. Also, not limiting to children, the internet being the new source of information and service provider everyone tends to rely on it for all they do (communication, purchases, research, etc) and possibly spending long hours when browsing.
Secondly, in terms of privacy, the documentary expresses its thoughts about privacy invasion by the providers. For example, with social networks like face book, hi5 and my space where membership is free, people can create personal profiles and put in all sorts of information about them, their life, profession, education and more for, their friends and maybe other people to view. Companies which promote their businesses online often send messages to these users promoting themselves and some times bombarding them with different deals and offers. In this case, the breach of confidentiality (mentioned when signing up) occurs and privacy is out of question. Face book at some point in time brought in the ‘news feed page’ where friends of friends or everyone could see updates on recent or new profile activities, hence limiting the degree of privacy on each individual’s profile. This is same for search engines like google maps which show specific locations of addresses up to the extent of pictures of the houses and streets. Nevertheless, it cannot be really assumed that there is privacy invasion with the internet per say. Taking again the case of social networks, privacy can only be invaded depending on the information the user puts on his or her profile. Hence, if the user is out to let the world know about their life by filling up their profile with much information, then yes, there will be no privacy. If the opposite is done, then users could keep their privacy. In other words, privacy is invaded depending on how much information is available to the public.

Lastly, the absorptiveness of the internet by its users could lead to anti-socialization in some cases. Back to the documentary where some parents complained about their children not paying much attention to them or bonding with them (like children and parent should) because they are always browsing was quite worrying. Face book has permitted many people to keep in touch, has helped to find old or lost friends and make new friends. In this sense, people keep track of each other and are aware of what is new through the news feed ( the digital loop of information to keep track of what people do) it created. Although this is a positive aspect and initiative, there are just some things the internet cannot really bring down such as social bonding which is more intense when you get to meet people face to face and building personalized relationships based on reality compared to the net which focuses on virtual relationships. With this argument, it is agreed that though the internet plays a good role in putting people back in touch, it limits itself to virtual relationships, different from the real ones.

In conclusion, yes the internet can be a burden all depending on how users adapt to it and make it as part of their daily activities, but on the other hand with the high dependency on the internet for almost everything, it remains a vital tool in our daily lives.

REFERENCE
BBC (2010) “the virtual revolution 4: Homo interneticus” [online] available from http://bbc.co.uk/virtualrevolution [25th February 2010]